Back in the UK, much is being made of the proposed eco-towns. These are supposed to be developments which encourage living in a more sustainable manner. However, none of them seem to be seriously tackling the problems of transport by making a serious effort to get people out of motor vehicles. The Dutch have tackled this by encouraging people to cycle.
Houten is a few kilometres South East of Utrecht. It dates back hundreds of years, however it was always a small town until the 1960s when it was targeted for growth. In the 1970s, the city's planners decided to discourage car use and encourage the use of bicycles. The city has grown rapidly since then, allowing a lot of new ideas to be built in at the point of design. It now has 47000 residents living with a very low road casualty rate and a very high cycling rate.
To quote from the Houten local government website: "There are 16 districts, each is only accessible to cars via a peripheral road encircling the town. A network of different types of paths for cyclists and pedestrians has been created throughout the area, with a direct backbone thoroughfare to the town centre. Only in residential streets cars are mixed with cyclists. Mostly all schools and important buildings are located along the cyclist's backbone."
We visited Houten on the 2006 Study Tour and found it a pleasure to cycle there.
Many of the principles established in the design of Houten have since been used in other new developments and existing cities around the Netherlands, including Assen where we base the Study Tours, particularly around the new suburb of Kloosterveen. However, other countries seem slow to pick up on what has been achieved.
Reading your posts gives me so many new insights on bicycle friendly communities. It also makes me frustrated about the place I live in. I don't know which one is greater in power, the insights gained or the frustration felt!
funny thing: I was born in Houten (1971), saw it expand from 3000 to more than a tenfold and yes, bumped into many foreign tv crews that were filming the 'green zones', aka bicycle infrastructure and zoning buffers.
Another fine example of carrot-and-stick policies.
I agree with Shek--hope and frustration. We just won't get there without some kind of energy crisis. Seems like Americans never get around to the things that matter until it's crashing around our ankles.
This looks so different to the Monderman approach. I'd love to see you contrast them. I was reading Simon Jenkin's article (http://tinyurl.com/4wyafb), and I got the sense that it's better than what's normal in the UK, but far behind the cyclist-prioritised designed you've shown.
Thanks for all the comments. Comparing segregation with shared space is a good idea. We have quite a bit of shared space around here, but to be honest I think it's over-rated.
In the English language press you tend to see only the somewhat idyllic representation that the enthusiasts have that somehow this has resolved all problems between motorists and cyclists. On the other hand, over here (and in some of the Dutch language comments on youtube) you also read the concerns of those who live with it. These often come from cyclists, including the national campaigning organisation Fietsersbond.
I took a couple of photos and a bit of video of the shared space in Oosterwolde a few months back which you can see here and here.
I'm beginning to see the potential in our village for more cycleways and less traffic. Just one question about implementation- how do the fire service get around? I'm asking because if I get involved in bike advocacy and we suggest blocking through streets, this will be the first question because we have eurpoe's largest print works on the edge of the village...
Added to the previous comment: I'm glad you have reservations about 'shared space': I'm not entirely convinced either: drivers seem to treat it as their space with pedestrian interlopers.
There are no roads which are completely blocked off and of course the cycle paths are wide enough that you could drive a fire engine along them in an emergency.
The bicycle roads are proper roads. They're the same width as they'd be if they weren't bicycle roads, it's just that they are legally prioritized for cyclists, and don't offer much of a through route for drivers.
I think having essentially flat ground helps to encourage cycling. The 'ECO?' town planned near me is all based on car travel - it would be better built somewhere closer to jobs and major centres of population. No-one in the UK will cycle 20+ miles a day - 2-4 miles maybe if fuel keeps going up. We need these examples to be real and a success not just property tycoons filling political donations.
Most cycle journeys all around the world are quite short, but designing a development around cars is the best thing you can do to encourage people to drive instead of cycle.
An article by Steve Melia discussed the way that Britain is not providing better permeability for cycles than cars. This is in large part the tragedy of the design of the Eco Towns.
BTW, referring to the Nethelands as being flat in this context is misleading. The country is (mostly) flat, but so are many highly populated areas of the UK which have much lower cycling. Switzerland has a higher cycling rate than the UK, and it's anything but flat. So, it's all about social issues surrounding cycling, and sadly the UK lost its cycling culture. That's what needs to be regained in order that cycling will increase. First of course you need to increase subjective safety to the extent that people will find cycling to be pleasant.
If you like this blog please support us so that it can continue. We're are not supported by grants and we do not ask for charity. We sell quality bicycle components and organize cycling holidays:
The next open study tour is in August 2013. Book a place in order to experience for yourself how policy and infrastructure in Assen and Groningen have led to the high cycling modal share in this area.:
The positive stuff Three types of safety - As well as preventing injuries and death, high quality cycling infrastructure addresses both subjective safety and social safety which are of vital importance in encouraging people to cycle. Dutch Safety Figures - Cyclists in the Netherlands are the safest in the world, but it has little if anything to do with "safety in numbers". Sustainable safety - the principles which have lead to Dutch roads, streets and cycle-paths being safe. A million per hour - The scale of cycling in the Netherlands is enormous. Dutch people make more cycle journeys each day than the entire English speaking world put together. Campaigning - a collection of posts about how to campaign for more cycling, including reference to "Stop the child murder", a successful campaign from the 1970s. What Works - examples of policy, infrastructure and campaigning which have made a different in the Netherlands. Superhighways - "Cycling superhighways" are not a new idea in the Netherlands Cycle Paths - Well designed cycle paths benefit all cyclists, regardless of experience or speed Segregation without cycle paths - you don't always need a cycle path to keep cyclists safe from motorists Unravelling of routes is vitally important History - how the Netherlands got to where it is now. See especially "Stop the child murder" Before and After - views of places before and after they have been transformed for cycling Directness - examples of prioritising cycling Traffic Lights - examples of how cyclists can be prioritised and kept safe at traffic light junctions. Note that it's almost always possible to turn right on a red light when cycling in the Netherlands. Roundabouts - roundabouts in the Netherlands have one very important feature to learn from: They keep cyclists away from motor vehicles. This is far more important than the differences in geometry vs. roundabouts in other countries. Exceptional infrastructure is always nice to see, but remember that a dense network of mundane routes is far more important to boost cycling modal share Gritting of cycle paths - dealing with snow and ice. Children - It may seem hackneyed, but children really are the future. If they can't cycle safely then where will future adult cyclists come from ? This is why children should be the primary focus of campaigners. Note also that according to UNICEF, Dutch children are the happiest in the world. School travel - Everyone knows that Dutch children cycle to school, but it's a surprise to many people that school trips are also usually by bike. Cycle Parking - including our favourite design of stand. Cycle Parking at railway stations, see in particular Groningen and Assen as each have multiple posts showing how the cycle parking has grown over time. Health effects of cycling Road Works - It's important that cyclists are thought of when there are road works. If the environment becomes hostile for cyclists then they may stop cycling and never start again. Commuting - Commuting cyclists are interesting, but they're not the only people who should ride bikes. Anatomy of a reliable everyday bicycle - the common features of bikes used by nearly every person every day in the Netherlands. Speed - Some people have the idea that Dutch cyclists are slow. This isn't true. It is just that in the Netherlands, everyone cycles, including the slow people. Fast cyclists are as fast as anywhere. These posts show people who ride faster than average, using the same infrastructure as those who ride slower.
This blog is free of charge to read and for most individual usage including reasonable "quoting" of its contents. However, neither the text nor the photos on this blog are in the public domain. To find out more, please read our copyright and licensing information.
Search
Non-sponsored links
Experience for yourself how policy and infrastructure in Assen and Groningen have led to the high cycling modal share in this area:
If you like this blog please support us so we can continue. We sell quality bicycle components and organize cycling holidays:
A cyclist in a cycling family living in the capital of the cycling province of the world's greatest cycling country.
I was born in the UK, lived for over 8 years in New Zealand and have lived in the Netherlands since 2007.
I organise cycling infrastructure study tours, run an online bicycle shop, arrange cycling holidays and write a popular blog about cycling.
My email address is avftcp@hembrow.eu
12 comments:
Reading your posts gives me so many new insights on bicycle friendly communities. It also makes me frustrated about the place I live in. I don't know which one is greater in power, the insights gained or the frustration felt!
Well, I do hope you're enjoying it regardless.
We certainly think it's good here, and certainly a lot less frustrating than where we used to live. That's why we moved here !
funny thing: I was born in Houten (1971), saw it expand from 3000 to more than a tenfold and yes, bumped into many foreign tv crews that were filming the 'green zones', aka bicycle infrastructure and zoning buffers.
Another fine example of carrot-and-stick policies.
I agree with Shek--hope and frustration. We just won't get there without some kind of energy crisis. Seems like Americans never get around to the things that matter until it's crashing around our ankles.
This looks so different to the Monderman approach. I'd love to see you contrast them. I was reading Simon Jenkin's article (http://tinyurl.com/4wyafb), and I got the sense that it's better than what's normal in the UK, but far behind the cyclist-prioritised designed you've shown.
Thanks for all the comments. Comparing segregation with shared space is a good idea. We have quite a bit of shared space around here, but to be honest I think it's over-rated.
In the English language press you tend to see only the somewhat idyllic representation that the enthusiasts have that somehow this has resolved all problems between motorists and cyclists. On the other hand, over here (and in some of the Dutch language comments on youtube) you also read the concerns of those who live with it. These often come from cyclists, including the national campaigning organisation Fietsersbond.
I took a couple of photos and a bit of video of the shared space in Oosterwolde a few months back which you can see here and here.
I'm beginning to see the potential in our village for more cycleways and less traffic. Just one question about implementation- how do the fire service get around? I'm asking because if I get involved in bike advocacy and we suggest blocking through streets, this will be the first question because we have eurpoe's largest print works on the edge of the village...
Added to the previous comment: I'm glad you have reservations about 'shared space': I'm not entirely convinced either: drivers seem to treat it as their space with pedestrian interlopers.
There are no roads which are completely blocked off and of course the cycle paths are wide enough that you could drive a fire engine along them in an emergency.
The bicycle roads are proper roads. They're the same width as they'd be if they weren't bicycle roads, it's just that they are legally prioritized for cyclists, and don't offer much of a through route for drivers.
Great insight David. Now if we could only get all that infrastructure over here!
I think having essentially flat ground helps to encourage cycling.
The 'ECO?' town planned near me is all based on car travel - it would be better built somewhere closer to jobs and major centres of population.
No-one in the UK will cycle 20+ miles a day - 2-4 miles maybe if fuel keeps going up. We need these examples to be real and a success not just property tycoons filling political donations.
Most cycle journeys all around the world are quite short, but designing a development around cars is the best thing you can do to encourage people to drive instead of cycle.
An article by Steve Melia discussed the way that Britain is not providing better permeability for cycles than cars. This is in large part the tragedy of the design of the Eco Towns.
BTW, referring to the Nethelands as being flat in this context is misleading. The country is (mostly) flat, but so are many highly populated areas of the UK which have much lower cycling. Switzerland has a higher cycling rate than the UK, and it's anything but flat. So, it's all about social issues surrounding cycling, and sadly the UK lost its cycling culture. That's what needs to be regained in order that cycling will increase. First of course you need to increase subjective safety to the extent that people will find cycling to be pleasant.
Post a Comment